Your toilet is one of the most used fixtures in your home. So, when it starts acting up, it’s not something you can just ignore. As a plumbing professional here in Evansville, I’ve seen everything from cracked bowls to toilets that waste gallons of water every day.
If you’re asking yourself whether it’s time to replace your toilet, I’ve got you covered. Below are some signs to watch for and tips that will help you make the right call.
Signs It Might Be Time to Replace Your Toilet
Sometimes, your toilet gives you a clear signal. Other times, it’s more subtle. Let’s take a look at a few red flags.
Constant Clogs
Does your toilet clog more often than it used to? If you’re reaching for the plunger weekly, that’s not normal. Older, low-flush models—especially those from the ’90s—tend to have this problem. Newer toilets have better flushing technology and are much more efficient.
Cracks in the Bowl or Tank
Small cracks might not seem like a big deal, but they can turn into leaks and water damage fast. If you see water pooling around the base or notice a crack in the porcelain, it’s time for a toilet replacement. It’s not worth the risk of a major leak.
Constant Repairs
If you’ve had to call for multiple toilet repairs in the past year—like fixing the flapper, handle, fill valve, or wax ring—it might be more cost-effective to replace the whole unit. Repairs add up quickly, and an upgrade can give you better performance and water savings.
How Old Is Your Toilet?
Age alone isn’t always a deal-breaker, but if your toilet is over 20 years old, it’s definitely worth evaluating. Older toilets often use up to 6 gallons of water per flush. Modern toilets only use 1.28 to 1.6 gallons—and they flush just as well (if not better).
Upgrading can save money on your water bill and help reduce your home’s environmental footprint.
Rocking or Leaking at the Base
A toilet that rocks or wobbles isn’t just annoying—it can also damage your floor. It usually means the wax seal is failing or the flange is broken. If there’s water leaking at the base, mold and rot can follow. In many cases, it’s best to go ahead and replace your toilet rather than patch things up.
Outdated Style or Poor Comfort
Sometimes, a toilet just doesn’t fit your lifestyle anymore. Maybe the seat is too low, the design feels dated, or you’re remodeling your bathroom. A modern toilet can enhance both the look and function of your space. Comfort-height models, bidet features, or soft-close lids are simple upgrades that make a big difference.
Benefits of Replacing Your Toilet
Still on the fence? Here’s what you can expect when you decide to move forward with a toilet replacement:
- Better water efficiency = lower bills
- Improved performance = fewer clogs
- More comfort and style
- Fewer repairs in the future
- Peace of mind knowing it’s done right
Trust the Plumbing Pros at Brackett
Here in Evansville and the surrounding tri-state area, we’ve been helping families since 1949 with trusted plumbing solutions. At Brackett Heating, Air & Plumbing, we know how important it is to get the job done right. Our team is fully licensed, insured, and committed to the kind of service that represents The Brackett Difference—honest, reliable, and top quality every time.
Ready to Replace Your Toilet? Let’s Talk.
If you’re seeing the signs, do not wait for a full-blown plumbing emergency. Whether it’s a quick swap or part of a larger bathroom upgrade, we’re here to help.
Call Brackett Heating, Air & Plumbing today or schedule an appointment online. We’ll walk you through the options and handle your toilet replacement with care, expertise, and the same family values we’ve stood behind for more than 70 years.
Don’t flush time and money down the drain—get the job done right with Brackett!
